Best Overall
Winmau Diamond Plus
Key details
- Weight
- 10.5 lb
- Board Material
- Sisal
- Included Darts
- Two sets
- Wall Protection
- Surround plus cabinet doors
The box holds more than a board and a cabinet: two sets of darts, an oche line, chalk, a scoreboard, a towel, and a surround, the ring that frames the board and takes the darts that sail past it.
That surround is the first reason we rank this one first. Cabinet doors only protect the strip of wall they cover, and a dart that misses the board low tends to find the wall below the door line; the surround catches it. The second reason is the board itself, which pairs a staple-free bullseye with wiring designed to reduce bounce-outs, and in our games it held darts more reliably than anything else in this group. Self-healing sisal closes up after the tips come out, so the face stays flat instead of going fuzzy.
Winmau also supplies the mounting hardware and a bracket that stands the board off the wall, and at 10.5 pounds the whole set goes up without drama. That matters more than it sounds. A cabinet that hangs crooked, or pulls loose the first time someone slams a door, ends the project before the first game.
The details are right in the small ways too. The chalk scoreboard is part of the package rather than an afterthought, the oche line sticks down once and then disappears, and the darts in the box are playable rather than disposable. We came away thinking the money went into the board and the wall protection, which is the right order.
Pros
- Board holds darts with few bounce-outs
- Surround protects wall past the doors
- Two dart sets, oche line and scoreboard included
- Light enough to hang on the supplied bracket
Cons
- Cabinet is a plain black box, not furniture
- Costs more than the budget pick here
We recommend the Diamond Plus to anyone starting from nothing: it is the most complete set here, and the board inside it is the one we trust most to hold a dart.